The TCG Vault vs Collectr

Collectr is the app a lot of collectors start with: point your phone at a card and it lands in your portfolio. The TCG Vault is a website built for a different job: getting every card on the right printing, finishing sets, and keeping your collection portable. Here’s where each one is the better pick, going by Collectr’s own pages and what The TCG Vault does today.

By Gob, GOB Industries · checked 30 October 2026

Side by side

As of October 2026. Collectr’s details are from its own website, web app and App Store listing, read on 30 October 2026; prices and features change, so check theirs before you decide.

CollectrThe TCG Vault
AppsiPhone, iPad and Android apps, plus a web app.A website that works on phone and desktop. No App Store or Google Play app.
Add cards by cameraYes. Unlimited scanning is a PRO feature.No. Search for the printing, or import a CSV.
GamesPokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Lorcana and 20+ more.14: Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Lorcana, One Piece, Final Fantasy, Star Wars: Unlimited, Digimon, Gundam, Flesh and Blood, Palworld, Riftbound, Cyberpunk TCG and tokidoki.
Exact printingIts scanner identifies the set, number and variant.Yes: set, collector number and finish, like foil, reverse holo or 1st Edition.
Price updatesDaily, from real sales data.Nightly, from TCGplayer market prices and game databases like Scryfall and pokemontcg.io.
Price historyUp to 5+ years with PRO.Sealed: every nightly price, charted, with Pro. Singles: the current and previous price only.
Sealed productYes.Yes: booster boxes, ETBs, bundles, blisters and packs.
Set checklistsNot mentioned on its site or App Store listing.Yes: every set, with a list of the cards you're missing. A Pro feature.
Import from other appsNot mentioned on its site or App Store listing.Collectr, TCGplayer, ManaBox, Moxfield, Deckbox, Archidekt, Dragon Shield, TopDecked and more, or any CSV.
ExportData export with PRO.CSV on every plan, free included, or shaped for ManaBox, Moxfield or Guardian TCG.
CommunitySocial feed, showcases, creator profiles and a Discord.None built in.
Free planFree to start. PRO adds unlimited scanning, export and longer price history.Unlimited cards and sealed, with live prices, import and CSV export.
Paid planPRO: $59.99 a year or $7.99 a month.Pro: $39.99 a year or $4.99 a month, for set checklists, price history, movers and graded values. New accounts get 14 days free.

Where Collectr is better

Scanning at the table

Point your camera at a card and Collectr identifies the set, number and variant, then adds it in seconds. The TCG Vault has no scanner: you search for the card or import a file.

Real phone apps

Native apps for iPhone, iPad and Android, plus a web app. The TCG Vault is a website only.

More games

Collectr lists 20-plus games, including Dragon Ball, Weiss Schwarz, Vanguard, Sorcery and Grand Archive, none of which The TCG Vault covers.

A community

A social feed, showcases, creator profiles and a Discord. The TCG Vault has no social side.

Long price history and graded data

PRO carries up to 5+ years of price history, and the price guide includes graded comps and pop reports. The TCG Vault keeps only the current and previous price for singles.

Extras

A trade analyzer, and values in any currency, crypto included. The TCG Vault shows US dollars only.

Where The TCG Vault is better

Set checklists

Every set shows how close you are and lists the exact cards you’re missing, so you know what to hunt next. Collectr’s site and App Store listing don’t mention set checklists. A Pro feature.

Export on every plan

Download your whole collection, singles and sealed, as a CSV on the free plan too, or shaped for ManaBox, Moxfield or Guardian TCG. Collectr lists data export as a PRO feature.

Imports from the apps you already use

Bring a collection in from Collectr, TCGplayer, ManaBox, Moxfield, Deckbox, Archidekt, Dragon Shield, TopDecked, MTGGoldfish, PriceCharting, Ludex and more, or any spreadsheet with name, set and number columns. Importing is free.

A printing you can check

Every imported row shows the printing it matched: set, collector number, and finish like foil, reverse holo or 1st Edition. Change it before it saves, and the nightly price follows that exact printing.

A lower Pro price

Pro is $39.99 a year or $4.99 a month. Collectr PRO is $59.99 a year or $7.99 a month on its App Store listing.

How a collection moves through The TCG Vault, in four steps: 1, bring your collection in from a Collectr, TCGplayer, ManaBox or Moxfield export or any spreadsheet; 2, check the set, collector number and finish each row matched (for example Charizard, Base Set #4, Holo) and change it before it saves; 3, prices refresh every night from TCGplayer and game databases like Scryfall, for that exact printing; 4, export a CSV on every plan, or a file shaped for ManaBox, Moxfield or Guardian TCG.

Questions

Can I move my collection from Collectr to The TCG Vault?

Yes. Export your collection from Collectr (its App Store listing lists data exports as a PRO feature), then upload the file on The TCG Vault's Import page. The Vault recognises Collectr's export, matches each row to a printing and shows you every match, so you can fix one before it saves. Importing is free on every plan, and the free plan has no limit on how many cards you bring in.

Does The TCG Vault have a phone app or a card scanner?

No. The TCG Vault is a website that works in your phone's browser, but there's no App Store or Google Play app and no camera scanning. You add cards by searching for the exact printing or by importing a CSV. If you mostly add cards by scanning them at the table, Collectr is built for that.

Can I export my collection without paying?

Yes. Every plan, the free one included, can download the whole collection, singles and sealed, as a CSV at any time. You can also download it shaped for ManaBox, Moxfield or Guardian TCG, or as a TCGplayer Mass Entry list.

Does The TCG Vault keep price history?

For sealed product, yes: every nightly price is kept and charted. For singles it keeps the current price and the one before it, which is enough to show what moved but not a long-term chart. Collectr says PRO gives up to 5+ years of price history, so if long card charts matter to you, that's a point for Collectr.

Sources

Questions? Contact us at [email protected].

More from The TCG Vault

Weighing more than one tracker? There’s the same side-by-side for The TCG Vault vs TCGVisor. For the whole of The TCG Vault, see what it tracks and how it prices your cards, what the free plan and Pro include, and who makes it.